Is Your Business Structure Raising Red Flags for Tax Authorities?

May 29
Detecting Artificial Separation in Business: Key Factors Explained
Artificial separation occurs when a business splits into smaller entities to gain tax advantages that are meant for small businesses. To ensure fair taxation, the Federal Tax Authority (FTA) scrutinizes such practices. Here's a simple explanation of how the FTA identifies artificial separation, with practical examples.

Financial Links
What to Look For:
Financial Support: Does one entity lend or give money to another? If one part of the business can't survive without the other's financial help, it could indicate artificial separation.

Example:
Before: "ABC Ltd." operates as one large company.
After: "ABC Ltd." splits into "ABC Tech" and "ABC Support." If "ABC Support" needs regular financial help from "ABC Tech" to stay afloat, it shows they might not be truly independent.
Economic Links
What to Look For:
Mutual Benefits: Do the entities benefit each other’s activities?
Shared Customers: Do they serve the same group of customers?

Example:
Before: "Smith's Electronics" sells and repairs electronics under one roof.
After: They split into "Smith's Sales" and "Smith's Repairs." If both businesses are still targeting the same customers and benefiting from each other's services, it's a sign of artificial separation.
Organizational and Structural Links

What to Look For:
  • Shared Premises and Equipment: Do they operate from the same location or use the same tools?

  • Common Management: Are they managed by the same people or have overlapping directors?

  • Shared Employees: Do the same workers serve both entities?

  • Joint Marketing: Do they advertise together?

  • Customer Awareness: Would a customer realize they are dealing with two separate businesses?


Example:
Before: "Healthy Living" operates as a single health and wellness center.
After: It splits into "Healthy Living Gym" and "Healthy Living Spa." If both parts are run by the same manager, share the same employees, and operate from the same building, this might be artificial separation. Additionally, if they market themselves together as "Healthy Living" and customers see them as one entity, it's another red flag.

Genuine Circumstances vs. Artificial Separation
It's important to note that there are legitimate reasons for businesses to operate multiple entities. For instance, two businesses might share premises due to high rental costs or employees might work for multiple businesses by choice. Therefore, the FTA looks at the overall context and multiple factors before concluding artificial separation.

Conclusion
Artificial separation to gain tax benefits is against the law and the FTA is vigilant in detecting such practices. By understanding financial, economic, and organizational links, businesses can ensure they remain compliant with tax laws and avoid penalties.
By keeping your business practices transparent and genuine, you contribute to a fairer economic environment. Always consult with a tax professional if you're unsure about your business structure to stay on the right side of the law.
Created with