How Splitting Your Business Can Lead to Tax Trouble: Learn More!

May 29
Understanding Artificial Separation in Business: A Simple Guide
Artificial separation happens when a business splits its activities into different parts to benefit from tax relief meant for small businesses. This can lead to unfair advantages and is something tax authorities, like the Federal Tax Authority (FTA), are keen to prevent. Let's break this down into simpler terms and look at some practical examples.

What is Artificial Separation?
Imagine you run a large business, but to pay less tax, you break it down into smaller parts, each claiming to be an independent small business. These parts, on their own, might qualify for Small Business Relief, but together, they exceed the threshold and should not be eligible for such relief. This intentional fragmentation to avoid higher taxes is what's known as artificial separation.
The FTA's Role
The FTA has the power to counteract such tactics. If they find that a business has been artificially separated and the total revenue exceeds AED 3,000,000 in a tax period, the business won't qualify for Small Business Relief. The business will then have to pay the corporate tax it tried to avoid and might also face penalties.

Types of Artificial Separation
Artificial separation can take various forms:

  1. Functional Separation: Splitting different functions of a business. For example, a restaurant might separate its food sales from its drink sales into two different entities.

  2. Geographical Separation: Separating the same business activities across different locations. Think of a chain of cafes, each operating under a different business entity but essentially doing the same thing.

  3. Temporal Separation: Operating the business through different entities at different times. For example, multiple legal entities might run a business one after the other, each stopping before hitting the Small Business Relief threshold. Or different companies might claim to operate only on certain days of the week.

Examples
Functional Separation Example:
Before: "John's Cafe" sells both coffee and pastries.
After: John splits his cafe into two businesses: "John's Coffee" and "John's Pastries." Each claims to be a separate small business to get tax relief, even though they operate in the same space and serve the same customers.
Geographical Separation Example:
Before: "Green Grocers" operates five stores across the city.
After: Each store is registered as a separate business entity, "Green Grocers North," "Green Grocers East," etc., to appear smaller and qualify for tax relief.
Temporal Separation Example:
Before: "Quick Fixers Ltd." provides handyman services throughout the year.
After: They create "Quick Fixers 1," "Quick Fixers 2," etc., each operating for a few months and then stopping, ensuring none of them exceeds the revenue threshold for Small Business Relief.
The Artificial Separation Test
The FTA conducts an artificial separation test to determine if a business is genuinely separate or artificially divided to evade taxes. They look at two main things:

Commercial Purpose: Is there a valid business reason for the separation other than tax benefits?
Same Business Activity: Are the separated entities essentially conducting the same business?
For the FTA to conclude artificial separation, both criteria must be met.

While businesses may have legitimate reasons to operate through multiple entities, doing so to dodge taxes is considered artificial separation and is against the law. The FTA is vigilant in identifying and addressing such practices to ensure a fair tax system.

By understanding and avoiding artificial separation, businesses can ensure they remain compliant with tax laws and contribute their fair share to the economy.
Created with